Ideas & Philosophy

Truth

A child tells his aunt the truth and is scolded for it. A scientist considers the many meanings of “truth”, and why everyone lies.

By Bernard Weiss 1 min read

A child’s parents have just taught him the importance of truth. They told him the story of George Washington and the cherry tree, which, by the way, is not true: it was a parable concocted by a 19th century preacher. The child then goes up to an aunt of his and says “You’re old, you’re fat and you’re ugly.” Even though he has followed the parents’ instructions, they are shocked. His behavior is met with less than their full approval. But that’s only if the lady were indeed old, fat, and ugly. Suppose the child had lied. Suppose she is young, and svelte, and beautiful. Then paradoxically, the parents would have been likely to laugh it off by say something like “Isn’t he cute.” Our social relations are based on tact rather than on truth. Tact relies on distorting or withholding the truth, which is tantamount to lying. Tact and diplomacy are form a glue that holds our society together. We all lie, and that’s the truth.

Scientists, unlike most others, have a reverence for truth, They adhere to a definition of truth that is like no other. Truth is the whole truth. Half-truths and misleading statements are as bad as outright lies. Conflicting evidence is not swept under the rug; it has to be mentioned. It is part of the truth. This is why a scientist will never win a debate. Nothing is ever truly black or white. The scientist will honestly acknowledge an opponent’s argument while saying that it does not alter his overall conclusion. But in doing so, he loses debating points.


This is an excerpt. The full essay appears in One-Sided Conversations: Musings of a Scientist.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Comments appear after approval.

An occasional letter

Hear about new essays and the book.

When there is a new piece on the site, or news about the book, you will get a short note. Not often, and never anything else.

Occasional news and new essays only. No spam; unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy