The instructor for a course in psychiatry for first year medical students at Johns Hopkins felt intimidated by the class. Perhaps it was because he was a merely a psychologist and didn’t have an MD degree. Or maybe he had other hangups that made him feel inferior. One day he mentioned to the class that he believed they did not respect him. In response, one of the students said “How long have you felt this way?” What must of hurt him even more than her patronizing question was the fact that when she said this, she didn’t even look up from her knitting.
That night, the instructor lay awake trying to think of ways to assert his dominance. At last, he found the solution. He’d utilize the superior skills his education had given him. He’d use psychology.
The next day, he came to class with a hand-held tape recorder. He gave it to the closest student and asked him to record his hopes, dreams, and plans for the future and then to pass it to the next student. It is daunting to have recorder shoved in your face when you are not prepared. At last, the instructor was one-up on the students. The student stammered and stuttered, he hemmed and he hawed. He finally blurted out a few words, and he quickly handed the recorder to his neighbor, who stammered and stuttered, etc. After about 5 or 6 students, the recorder came to Lowell.
Lowell refused to make a statement. He wasn’t naturally defiant. In fact, he was a gentle-mannered likable guy. He was married to a lovely young woman who had been his high school sweetheart and had helped him recover from a serious accident that maimed his arm and leg. Perhaps Lowell sensed the instructor was playing a game and that the best way to end a game is for one participant to stop. Lowell’s unexpected response blocked the instructor’s strategy. So the instructor coaxed, cajoled, implored, and tried to shame Lowell. And when this did not work, he coaxed, cajoled, implored, and shamed again.
Finally, Lowell gave in and said “I’ll tell you what I want to be. I’ve discussed it with my family because it has one of the longest training periods of all the medical specialties. I want to be a NEUROSURGEON!” And with that, Lowell took his arm out from under the conference table, where it had been resting on his lap, and banged the table with his prosthetic metal claw.
(Lowell Rogers, MD [1945-2013]. Lowell became a pathologist.)
From One-Sided Conversations: Musings of a Scientist by Bernard Weiss.