In 1854, there was a small but deadly cholera epidemic in London. The physician John Snow noticed that many cases clustered around a public water pump on Broad Street. He believed that the infections were caused by contaminated water from the pump. Most authorities, however, “knew” that cholera was caused by miasma (bad air). Nevertheless, Snow persuaded the officials to remove the pump handle. The epidemic stopped abruptly. This marked the beginning of the science of epidemiology, of which John Snow is considered the founder. He is still regarded as a hero in England.
This story sounds like a fairy tale. It paints a rosy picture of human nature that is contrary to our experience. It was certainly not manifest during our recent COVID-19 pandemic when public anger was directed against quarantine measures and the people who promoted them. What would happen at the Broad Street pump today?
The pump would be surrounded by a noisy, angry crowd carrying empty buckets. They would protest about having to carry their pails of water a few extra blocks. How dare the government deny them their natural right to water. The police would be called, and there would be injuries on both sides. That night, someone would steal the handle from another pump. The next day the police would seize it, only to have it replaced the following night with a jerry-rigged wooden one that several protesters would protect with firearms. Dr. Snow would be hanged in effigy. His house and carriage would be covered with graffiti. His tires would be slashed. He’d receive hate mail and death threats daily. Someone would kill his cat. An outgoing president would feel the need to pardon him from any future prosecution. He’d be vilified by congressmen who would attack him for the inconveniences they suffered during attempts to slow a lethal epidemic.
Why are our reactions so different today from what they were 170 years ago? Is it because human nature has deteriorated during the past two centuries? Probably not. People were just as vile then as today. After all, in 1854, the most popular form of family entertainment in England was the public execution. I believe the difference in our reaction lies in our current concept of freedom in America. We have come to view it as a God-given right that we can passively enjoy. We ignore that it requires active participation. Many people do not recognize that they must give up their selfish exercise of some of their personal freedoms when it encroaches on the freedom, rights, and welfare of others.
From One-Sided Conversations: Musings of a Scientist by Bernard Weiss.