People say “Everybody cheats on their taxes; why pick on me?” Or, “Everybody speeds; why should I get a ticket?” There is a common misconception that in numbers, there is innocence.
Five people rob a bank, and one of them kills a guard. Do they each get one-fifth of a robbery conviction? No. They may each think that they were just going along with the others and therefore deserve no more than a partial sentence. The getaway driver may argue that he didn’t even enter the bank. But the law does not absolve them. They may each receive a full sentence. In many jurisdictions, they might all be charged with felony murder even though four of them carried no gun. And yet, it is common for most people to think that when they act in a group, they they no longer have any personal responsibility.
Most people in a lynch mob would not commit murder on their own. A rioting crowd is not composed entirely of violent hooligans. The majority are otherwise decent people who are just angry. They mistakenly believe that they can divest themselves of personal responsibility for illegal and immoral activity under the umbrella of a crowd’s group liability.
The ten members of a firing squad pick up their weapons. Nine are loaded with a single bullet. The tenth has a blank round. Theoretically, each member of the squad can convince himself that he may have not killed another human being. This is a silly. They are all responsible.
A holdout on a jury ultimately votes for the death penalty because of pressure from the other eleven members who want to get home. In doing so, he rationalizes his decision to abandon his personal responsibility by saying that his vote was supported by eleven others. He believes that he only deserves one-twelfth of the responsibility. Once again, the mob rules. I’m not completely opposed to the death penalty, but as a jury member I’d vote for it only if I were prepared to pull the switch myself.
In gangster movies, a newcomer who wants to belong to a mob, must first commit a crime. They can’t trust anyone who is not a criminal like themselves. I’ve seen the same behavior among workers in a government organization in which no one did his job. A new employee was not to be trusted until his co-workers could get something on him. The theory is that no one can be called a derelict if no one is diligent. Once again, if everyone acts the same way, it must be OK.
Will we ever accept personal responsibility for our own actions, even when we act in a group?
From One-Sided Conversations: Musings of a Scientist by Bernard Weiss.