Human Nature

Nobody Wins an Argument

When have you ever seen one party to an argument admit that he’s wrong?

By Bernard Weiss 1 min read

When have you ever seen one party to an argument get the other to admit that he’s wrong? No amount of rhetoric, logic, or emotion ever triumphs in the moment. The argument is viewed by both parties as an assault on their personhood, and they are obliged to defend themselves at any cost. People often get emotional when they argue. The emotional content of any argument is inversely proportional to its rational basis. Don’t try to reason with the irrational; it’s a waste of time. Parents learn that they cannot reason with a two-year-old, and psychologists learn that they can’t reason with someone who’s delusional.

When my daughter was a teenager, she’d frequently argue with me. It was frustrating. Why couldn’t she trust my superior judgment that was based on years of experience and on values I had instilled in her? Then, a week or two later, I’d hear her talking to her friends and using the same words that I had used. I realized that confrontation was her way of learning. And so it is with most adults as well. You may not get someone to admit that you are right, but your reasoning will eventually have an impact on his thoughts.


From One-Sided Conversations: Musings of a Scientist by Bernard Weiss.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Comments appear after approval.

An occasional letter

Hear about new essays and the book.

When there is a new piece on the site, or news about the book, you will get a short note. Not often, and never anything else.

Occasional news and new essays only. No spam; unsubscribe any time. Privacy policy